Equal Housing Opportunity NYS Housing and Anti-Discrimination Notice

Signature Premier Properties, 7 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787 Office: (631) 360-2800

Signature Premier Properties
Stephanie Calinoff at Signature Premier Properties

NY · Long Island

Middle Island

5 closed sales, median $215,000, typically 43 days on market.

See homes for sale Ask what your home is worth

ZIP code
11953
School district
Longwood
Typical property taxes
$10,128

a year, median of the homes for sale

Typical year built
1991

median of the homes for sale

Stephanie’s sales here
5

since 2014, $97,500 to $552,500

School districts, taxes and year built describe the homes for sale in Middle Island today; taxes and year built are medians. Data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID as of November 8, 2026.

Overview

Middle Island today

Homes for sale in Middle Island today have a median asking price of $547,000. Two-bedroom homes are asking a median of $470,000, three-bedroom homes $597,000, four-bedroom homes $620,000 and homes with five or more bedrooms $849,950.

Data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID as of November 8, 2026. These are asking prices, not sold prices.

Stephanie Calinoff, a Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker and Realtor with Signature Premier Properties, has closed five sales in Middle Island since 2014, from $97,500 to $552,500.

On the market today

Middle Island market report

What sellers in Middle Island are asking on November 8, 2026, and how the asking prices are spread. These are the homes on the market, not homes that have sold.

Median asking price
$547,000

Based on 46 listings.

Median days on the market
47

Half have been listed longer than this. Based on 46 listings.

Median asking price per square foot
$333

Based on 46 listings.

New this week
2%

Came on the market in the past 7 days, 1 of 46 listings.

Asking prices, by band

  • Under $500,000
  • $500,000 to $550,000
  • $550,000 to $650,000
  • $650,000 and over

Bands are set from this town’s own quartiles, rounded. Based on 46 listings.

Median asking price, by bedrooms

2 bedrooms
$470,000

Based on 18 listings.

3 bedrooms
$597,000

Based on 20 listings.

4 bedrooms
$620,000

Based on 5 listings.

5 or more bedrooms
$849,950

Based on 3 listings.

A bedroom count with fewer than three homes for sale is left out.

Every figure above is a median or a share of the asking prices of homes for sale in Middle Island on November 8, 2026. Asking prices are what sellers want, not what homes have sold for. Data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID as of November 8, 2026.

Closed sales

Sold by Stephanie in Middle Island

5 closed sales in Middle Island since 2014, $97,500 to $552,500.

Every sale
  1. 125 Fairview Circle

    $265,000

    2 bd · 1.5 ba · 20 days on market

  2. 40 Woodville Road

    $552,500

    5 bd · 2 ba · 11 days on market

  3. 21 Bailey Court

    $97,500

    1 bd · 1 ba · 64 days on market

  4. 4 Greenbriar Court

    $206,500

    3 bd · 2 ba · 43 days on market

  5. 14 Greenbriar Court

    $215,000

    2 bd · 2 ba · 99 days on market

Figures are from Stephanie Calinoff's own closed transactions, data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID, covering September 2014 to June 2024.

Common questions about Middle Island real estate

How much do homes cost in Middle Island right now?

The median asking price of homes for sale in Middle Island on November 8, 2026 was $547,000. Half were priced between $486,000 and $665,225.

What kinds of homes are for sale in Middle Island?

Of the homes for sale in Middle Island on November 8, 2026, 54 percent were single family houses and 46 percent condominiums. The median home had 3 bedrooms and about 1,575 square feet.

What are property taxes like in Middle Island?

The median annual property tax on homes for sale in Middle Island on November 8, 2026 was $10,128. The median home was built in 1991.

What school district are homes in Middle Island in?

Most homes for sale in Middle Island on November 8, 2026 were in the Longwood school district.

How long have homes in Middle Island been on the market?

Half of the homes for sale in Middle Island on November 8, 2026 had been listed for 47 days or fewer, and 30 percent had come on the market in the past 30 days.

Answers are medians and shares of the homes for sale in Middle Island on November 8, 2026. Data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID as of November 8, 2026.

Own a house in Middle Island?

Stephanie will walk it and give you a number, plus the two or three things worth fixing before anyone sees it. No obligation, and no follow up campaign you have to unsubscribe from.

Ask for a price opinion

Get market updates from Stephanie

Stephanie will send occasional updates. You can stop them any time.

Privacy

Stephanie Calinoff Talk to Stephanie