Stephanie Calinoff
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker, Signature Premier Properties, Smithtown
Selling? Start with what your home is worth
I am committed to upholding the principles of all applicable Fair Housing Laws
Helping Suffolk sellers, buyers and downsizers.
Stephanie Calinoff has been selling Long Island homes since 1985, from the Signature Premier office in Smithtown where she grew up. She markets every listing herself, in print, online and through a network built over four decades, and walks every sale through personally.
Meet Stephanie
Stephanie Calinoff has been selling Long Island homes since 1985. Since 2012 alone she has closed 407 sales across 54 towns, roughly half for sellers and half for buyers. She works out of the Signature Premier Properties office in Smithtown, the town she grew up in.
Stephanie guides every sale herself, from the first call to the closing table.
What clients say about Stephanie
5.0 from 48 reviews on Google and 5.0 from 69 reviews on Zillow
Stephanie’s experience in the business was very impressive and really shone through during the home buying Process. Plus, she is hilarious and fun to work with!!
Stephanie was just great. Her patience in helping us find "just the rigjt home" was fantastic, and we were very very picky to say the least. Stephanie really made sure we seen different places to ensure we would find the place we really wanted. Her friendly sense of humor always kept our house hunting light and lively. Stephanie simply is someone youbwould want to be alongside of you during your house hunting experience.
The worst part about Steph and Joe… is that they’ll find you your dream home way too quickly and you won’t get to spend more of your time with them. We thought finding our first home would be incredibly difficult and frustrating, but Steph and Joe made the entire process so easy and fun. They were there day and night to answer our questions and hold our hands through the process. Their experience and knowledge is invaluable, but they also genuinely care about getting you into the right home. They’re great realtors, but even better people. I can not recommend them enough! 10/10, no notes.
We were struggling a bit with this review because we didn't want to come off as if we were getting paid to write it. Ultimately we decided to let the facts speak for themselves. My wife and I met Stephanie during the search for our first house over 27 years ago. In all that time Stephanie has helped us buy and sell a total of 7 homes for a total of 11 transactions to date. At one point she even helped us with an out of state relocation. After the first transaction we immediately realized that she did things differently from other agents. Since then our transactions have became a thing of real TRUST. Stephanie genuinely listens to us and never tries to steer or influence. At times even protecting us from ourselves when we have wanted to look at houses that we later came to realize would have been bad for us. Any attorney or finance agent she has recommended has always turned out to be top notch and it is an added bonus that she has access to these individuals during off hours. You know those moments when you want an answer to something but don't want to call your attorney at 10 P.M. Well she can and will on your behalf if the situation calls for it. She herself is always easy to reach and she will get that answer that you need. On this last transaction we joked that she is our artist and that we would just let her paint. Let me tell you she did not disappoint we bought / sold in one swoop and nothing is ever perfect but this transaction was close enough. I will wrap it up by stating that over these years she has become more than our agent. She is also a great friend. It doesn't matter that we don't connect, sometimes for months at a time, but when we do we pick up right where we left off. My wife and I will often joke that Stephanie will be representing us when it comes time for our nursing home accommodations. There are many good agents out there but you would be hard pressed to find someone as good and as real as Stephanie.
Stephanie is great. She will make you laugh and stick by your side throughout the whole process and after. She’s an amazing person and really passionate about her occupation.
Great experience, would absolutely recommend Stephanie to anyone looking to buy a home. She is very friendly, but definitely not afraid to stand up for her client. You could tell that she really cares about helping you find the best place to fit your needs.
It was such a pleasure to work with Stephanie. Stephanie and her team were all amazing throughout the entire home buying process. In this competitive housing market, the home buying process could have been such a challenge. Thanks to the expertise, reliability and guidance from Stephanie! We were able to navigate our way to finding a great forever home. From the very beginning, Stephanie made it a priority that our house search is targeted to the criteria we are looking for. Because we feel confident that we are constantly guided by a knowledgeable realtor like Stephanie, the home search experience becomes more and more enjoyable! The love and care Stephanie puts in to making her clients happy and satisfied is extra incredible. You are the best, Stephanie Calinoff!! Thank you!
Stephanie Calinoff has been amazing! She found our dream home and we couldn’t have done it without her and her team. Highly recommend!
Stephanie is fantastic!! She made the whole process very easy for us in our difficult time. I would recommend her to anyone who is looking to buy or sell. Even if you just have a few questions , she has so much knowledge to offer. Thank you Stephanie!!
Stephanie is the best. Excellent and professional.
Stephanie was wonderful to work with! She was always responsive, patient, and thoughtful throughout the process. She made everything less stressful and guided me with clear advice at every step. I’m so grateful for her support and highly recommend her.
Stephanie is the best of the best! She knows what she’s doing and man she is good at it! We spent two weekends with her going around looking at houses and there was always a plan laid out with the most efficient schedules which was so helpful for us as we were not based in the area. She helped us every step of the way including helping us find a lender to get our loan sorted, a house inspector, an attorney, and even a cleaning service for when we moved in! If she doesn’t have an immediate referral, that doesn’t stop her, she has so many trusted contacts that she gets it done for you. She’s always available by phone or text and she is truly the best to be around. We definitely recommend her and will be keeping a personal relationship with her too! Thanks Stephanie!!
Stephanie is a pleasure to work with. She stuck by me through the months that went by as several homes ended up not being the right one. She is professional with the right amount of brevity. She is positive even in the hard times. She has 40 years of experience in real estate and isn’t frazzled by the ups and downs. She is the right person to have in your corner.
I had the pleasure of working with Stephanie when purchasing my home, and it was a fantastic experience from start to finish. Stephanie is not only highly professional and knowledgeable, but also incredibly personable. She made the entire process feel smooth and stress-free. Throughout the transaction, her warm and friendly approach fostered a real sense of trust and even friendship. I highly recommend Stephanie to anyone looking for a seamless and enjoyable home-buying (and selling) experience.
Steph is literally heaven sent !! She made the process of buying a home so fun & encouraging . Don’t go to anyoone else unless its her . I promise you wont regret it ! Shes been in the game for a long time , shes well known and liked which is definitely something you want on your side . Steph is very well spoken as well , and shes funny lol . Buying a home is stressful but Thank God for her !!
Steph’s knowledge and experience of real estate is second to none. As first time home buyers, we felt like we were in over our heads until we met Steph. Steph wants nothing but the best for her clients and it shows. Her knowledge of real estate and her always helpful advice paved the way for us on our home buying journey. And it’s never a dull moment when she’s around. Steph really is one of a kind!
Stephanie is the best! She found us our dream home and secured it for us with her many connections in the industry and her talent of being the best agent ever! She also sold both my grandparents houses and secured a house for my sister as well! If you are looking to buy or sell call Stephanie!! We would not have found the house we did in this market without her. I recommend her to all my friends and family! She is simply the best!
I had the pleasure to work with Stephanie Calinoff from Premier Properties. She helped me sell my home. I wasn't able to be at the home or her office since i lived 2 and a half hours away. But she took care of everything.I was impressed by her professionalism and how Stephanie handled the whole process from start to finish. Stephanie kept in touch with me either by text, email or a phone call even for all the small information that she would receive. If you are thinking of buying or selling a property Stephanie can take care of you. I wish Stephanie a wonderful new year. Thank you Stephanie again for a smooth and perfect sale of my home. Ray Caamano.
Stephanie was great helping me buy a home. She totally understood what I was looking for and showed me many great properties. I would definitely work with Stephanie again should I have any further real estate dealings.
She is amazing, professional & enthusiastic. She made my house buying procces really smooth. I would love to have another time with her. Best of luck Stephanie 🤞
Stephanie Calinoff helped me during a tough time. I needed to get mom’s place sold quickly in order to transition her into assisted living. Stephanie was supportive in many ways and made the sale of my moms place a top priority. She remained in contact and guided me from start to finish. Her work ethic is impeccable. She will truly look out for you.
Stephanie is the most friendly and knowledgeable real estate agent. I have known her for years and when it came time to sell our house, we had no doubt she was the one to call. She sold our house very quickly and for the price we wanted. She was very professional in every phase of the process of selling our home and extremely helpful. She recommend the moving company that we used along with the lawyer we used. Would recommend her highly to anyone.
Selling a home isn’t always easy, Stephanie a true professional accomplished this and more. Stephanie advised my elderly mother and myself thru every detail, from setting a competitive price, marketing brochures to Open Houses. Stephanie alway answered all our questions and most important she sold our condo in a timely manor. Stephanie earned all 5 stars in our opinion.
Working with Stephanie made the process of selling our home a seamless one. She came highly recommended from our close friends, so I knew we were in good hands. Stephanie was always available to answer any questions we had and was beyond easy to work with. I would recommend her to anyone looking for a real estate agent. She is knowledgeable, trusting, and highly effective! We were nervous about the process but she made it very easy. Thank you Stephanie!!
When I decided to sell my house a close friend recommended Stephanie to me. She was outstanding the moment she walked in the door. Stephanie was confident, knowledgeable, responsive and incredibly thorough. Throughout the entire experience I felt she always had my best interest and her patience eased my decision making process. We had a professional photographer at our house and within a week we had offers well above our asking price. Stephanie is a true professional and truly understands how to sell houses. She’s the best realtor with a great team around her and I will highly recommend her to everyone I know buying or selling a house. Thank you again so much Stephanie!
Stephanie helped me move to the next chapter of my life by being patient and thorough and sharing her years of experience throughout the whole process of finding my new home. I would not have wanted to take that journey with any other real estate professional. I'll be forever grateful and highly recommend her!
Stephanie sold us our first home 16 years ago and then 16 years later sold that same home in a matter of a few days. Our family just loves her professionalism and bubbly personality. She is very easy to reach via text or phone call. She also helped us find our dream home! If you need a great agent who’s reliable, use Stephanie Calinoff.
I met with Stephanie Calinoff in the year, 2018 when I decided to buy an apartment in Ronkonkoma, NY. Stephanie showed me multiple apartments with patience and virtual tours in a timely manner. She did a fantastic job, efficient, and very professional, and finally helped me in buying the desired apartment. In May 2021 I have relocated to Charlotte, North Carolina and approached Stephanie to list the same apartment in the market. She did wonderful job and she truly understands how to sell houses, she made the process incredibly easy and her thorough knowledge, not only of general real estate but of the local market made it a great pleasure throughout the process. I strongly recommend to everyone who're in the process to buy or sell houses, approach Stephanie and get it done efficiently and quickly. Regards, Malla Reddy Polala
Dear Stephanie, Thank you so much for all of your help! We are so grateful for all of the hard work you've done to not only help us to buy our home, but to find our dream home as well. We are endlessly grateful to have you as our agent and couldn't be happier with the way everything worked out I will also refer you to my friends, family, and colleagues who need real estate assistance in the future. Thank you again for all your care and attention .You're the best! Review: Stephanie is the best! She helped my husband and I buy our first house. She made the experience so easy and enjoyable, especially for first-time home-buyers like us. She is quick to respond, always happy to help, and the most supportive and joyful. Stephanie made our home purchasing process easy and smooth! Her guidance and help was very much appreciated.. Stephanie was excellent. She was knowledgeable, helpful and made this process incredibly easy. We can not say enough great things about her! She is the BEST realtor I could have hoped for. She went above and beyond. She anticipated needs and met them all with a smile on her face and expert advice. She was an absolute pleasure to work with and made the purchasing of our new home seamless. We feel so blessed that she was our realtor. She is unbelievable communicator. She does an excellent job making sure the families she works with understand the process of buying or selling, important deadlines and makes sure that there are no unexpected issues with the closing. We recommend Her whole-heartedly! We will definitely refer family and friends to Stephanie in the future.
Stefanie did a fantastic job selling our condo. She was able to sell our home quickly, for the price we needed. She helped us overcome every challenge like the true professional she is.
Stephanie and I has been a referral partner and friend of mine for over 20 years...She is an extremely hard worker and a full time agent for over 30 years...What I love about Stephanie is she listens to the buyers needs to make sure she shows them the right home that meets their criteria. She is always available 7 days a week via phone, text or email.....If you are looking to purchase a home, Stephanie is the right choice for your home buying needs
I 💯 percent recommend that you go with Stephanie Calinioff when looking to purchase a home. She is reliable, professional and has great experience. Stephanie helped us get the house we wanted in the neighborhood we wanted. Thank you Stephanie.
Going into this market without a Stephanie on your corner would be a huge misstep! Stephanie is my real estate Godmother. She’s kept us well-informed and has done all that was possible to get us the house we fell in love with. We love you, Steph!
5 stars isn't enough! If you are looking for someone who will get you results and work for you..then look no further Had a bad experience with another realtor--Stephanie was recommended to me and she hit the ground running and found me a place--wasn't easy during the pandemic--but she did it!. You will not be disappointed!
Stephanie was wonderful to work with while I was selling my home!! She was a professional & so knowledgeable about every aspect of real estate. She kept me calm with her down to earth sense of humor & positivity. During something that could be so stressful I felt so secure in her care as she guided me through every step. No one is better!!
Stephanie is the best!!! She helped us find the home of our dreams in a very tough market. We have recommended her to family and friends and everyone has had a great experience. Don't wait to call her. You won't be sorry!
There is seriously no one better than Stephanie! She walked us through every step of purchasing a home. Offer after offer, we were always runner-up. Stephanie stood by our side and was determined to find us our home. The day after our wedding, she presented us with the exciting news of a seller accepting our offer. This was the best wedding gift we could’ve asked for. She is charismatic and energenic. Would not choose another realtor.
Stephanie was our realtor when we purchased our first home, and was our realtor when we sold it. Always helpful, super responsive, and beyond personable. She helped me stay at ease through both processes, as we know not all home buying and selling experiences are easy. It’s definitely always a stressful time. But her guidance helped me through it. I even got cold feet to sell because of my emotional attachment to my home, and she let me know it was perfectly normal to feel that way and that I would not regret it. She was 100 percent right! She has an energy about her that vibrates just awesomeness and wholesomeness!! I hope those are words! Lol if not, that’s how I perceive her! We had moments where we pointed out “this was a sign” which I’m big on and so is she! I loved working with her!! If I didn’t move out of state, she would be my realtor FOR LIFE! I will always remember Stephanie! I can’t leave this review without expressing her most best trait! She is funny as hell!! Always a laugh! And a fun experience! If you need a realtor, don’t miss out on this amazing soul!!!!
I was selling the house I grew up in under sad circumstances. Stephanie made the process seamless and was a joy to do business with. I learned so much about real estate and she put my mind at ease. It was truly a gift to have met her.
I would recommend Stephanie to anyone I know if they are looking to buy a home! She was relentless until she found our perfect home and made the process incredibly easy. She is the best on Long Island, hands down!
As a first time homebuyer I was lost as to how to start searching for a house. Luckily I was referred to Stephanie Calinoff through my loan officer. It was the best thing to happen to me. She always had my best interest in mind. It just wasn’t about getting a new client, but taking the time to find the right home for me and my family. She was always available to answer any questions or concerns I had. In the midst of this pandemic she always had a positive attitude which kept me in good spirits throughout the process. She has made my dream of being a homeowner a reality. I will be forever grateful for all her hard work.
I was introduced to Stephanie through a friend and interviewed several agents, ultimately deciding to move forward with her. I had an immediate connection and she answered numerous questions before I even signed with her. She is extremely responsive, always picks up the phone or gets back to you immediately, and has a sense of urgency which is necessary in this market! She knew exactly what we were looking for and could read our minds immediately every time upon walking into a house! She dealt with our craziness throughout the process and really was the BEST!! Her sense of humor is what got us through the stresses of it all and she made it as painless as possible. There were times she went above and beyond to make things happen! She sold my home in 2 days with 11 offers all over asking! She always had our interests at heart and would do anything for us! Through all of this, I have gained a friend for life!
I met with Stephanie Calinoff in 2018 when I decided to buy an apartment in Ronkonkoma, NY. Stephanie showed me multiple apartments with pictures and virtual tours in a timely manner. She did a fantastic job, it was quick, efficient, and very professional, and finally helped me in buying the desired apartment. I was relocated to Charlotte, NC in May 2021 and approached Stephanie to list the same apartment in the market. She truly understands how to sell houses, she made the process incredibly easy and her thorough knowledge, not only of general real estate but of the local market made it a great pleasure throughout the process. I strongly recommend to everyone who's in the process to buy or sell houses, to approach Stephanie and get it done quickly. Regards, Malla Reddy Polala
I have used many different brokers over the years. A few were decent but it always ended in the same way, I fired them. Poor communication , not getting back to me in a timely fashion and not paying attention to detail. That has all changed since I met Stephanie a few years back. She is Top Notch and I consider her the upper echelon. No need to look any further she is always ready to roll up her sleeves to get the job done correctly.
I was recommended to Stephanie through a friend and we started talking long before the pandemic. We were all set to meet with her and that was the day the country was shut down! We put everything on hold and once everything started opening back up, it was go time! She sold our house in 2 days with 11 offers over asking and was patient with us to find a home that suited our needs. It was quite the task, that’s for sure!! She knew exactly what we were looking for and would read our minds as soon as we walked into a house! We had several stresses throughout our process but her sense of humor is really the best and what got us through it all! She really made the process fun! We totally clicked and she was absolutely AMAZING!! She has a sense of urgency, always responds quickly, answers her phone, and will jump through hoops to make things happen! She was also my “therapist” through all of this and was an ear at all times!! Lol. She truly is the BEST!!
Stephanie was absolutely amazing! After the first time we met I knew that we would work well together. My husband and I were looking for a home with mother/daughter features and it was definitely hard with our price range, but Stephanie made it all happen. She listened to what we were looking for and could automatically read our faces when we stepped in a home as to whether or not we loved it. Stephanie tells it like it is and felt comfortable enough to tell us whether or not she felt that a house was worth it. We didn’t want to have to fix up a house too much and if it involved a little bit of cosmetic work it was a go. Stephanie got us a showing of our house before the open house. We actually got to meet the owner and after talking with him for a bit my husband and I stood out (along with Stephanie’s smooth talking). We put an offer in and 2 days later we were called telling us they accepted our offer. We couldn’t have done it without you Stephanie and so grateful that you helped us find our forever home!
Words cannot express how grateful we are to have met Stephanie! We called Stephanie to discuss the possibility of buying a new home during Covid. We were scared and had no knowledge. Stephanie held our hand and had numerous phone calls with us to let us know that she would find us the perfect house and that she did! She was able to list our home and sell within 4 days and over asking price! She is extremely knowledgeable and has the best agent connections, she is well respected in the real estate community and because of that she was able to find us our dream home! We are forever grateful! Thank you, Stephanie!
Looking for a home is generally a stressful and time-consuming process in normal times. Even more so in the midst of a global pandemic. Especially if you’re moving from the city to a red hot suburban market, not being able to see the property in person before committing to it. We were so fortunate to have found Stephanie Calinoff with Douglas Elliman when we decided to move from Brooklyn to Suffolk County. As our Real Estate Advisor, she helped us find the right house in the right neighborhood for the right price. She was super patient as we traveled from Brooklyn to look at homes over several weeks. She also cautioned us about unreasonable offers when we fell too quickly for overpriced homes. In short, she was always on our side working to make our purchase as streamlined and successful as possible. The best part about working with Stephanie was that she was always more focused on our objective by giving us good advice, and finding homes that met our specific needs than she was on just closing a deal.
Stephanie is a fantastic agent. She was always available and responsive to my questions and concerns, even during weekends and evenings, and she was very supportive throughout the whole process, especially since this was my first time buying a home. I was pretty picky and I was looking for a condo in a specific complex. When one unit became available, Stephanie texted me right away. She got me a showing the next day and my offer was accepted that same evening. Any question I had about the condo, she communicated with the seller’s agent right away and I got an answer within a few minutes. Overall, thanks to Stephanie, my first experience buying a home was a pleasant one. I would highly recommend Stephanie to anyone considering to sell or buy a home.
If you're looking to sell OR buy (or both as in my case) in Long Island Stephanie is the PERSON to deal with ! I've used Stephanie 3 times....once to sell a home in Smithtown, which went quickly, effectively and for the right price ! Then I moved back to Smithtown 7 years later and had a home purchase fall through 10 days before closing....and I needed to buy a house immediately...I called Stephanie, who was on vacation and 24 hours later I had a contract on a wonderful home. Fast forward 9 years, and a company relocation. Stephanie was pitted against two other agents by relocation company and won out due to her incredible accuracy on my home value and she sold for exactly the predicted value....and did so quickly. 16 years of working with Stephanie (and her wonderful mom early on). There's none better !
I loved working with Stephanie! She is extremely knowledgeable about the market/area and steered me correctly, when she thought a listing wasn’t worth my time. She also seemed to “get me” and what I was looking for, so she was an excellent sounding board. Not to mention, Stephanie has a great personality and sense of humor, which completely made a potentially stressful situation, an easy one. Actually, her ability to connect with others helped me land a house that wasn’t even on the market! I highly recommend Stephanie and would absolutely work with her again!
Stephanie is a pleasure to work with and made herself available 24/7 for any questions or concerns. She listened to what our family's unique needs and location specifications to help us find the right house quickly. Stephanie's knowledge of the area and amazing relationships with mortgage brokers, banks, inspectors and lawyers made the whole process easy, better than my last go round buying a house. I highly recommend, you will not be disappointed and she will work with you every step of the way to make sure you get what you are looking for and the best customer service. She has a great sense of humor as well.
Stephanie was recommended to my husband and I after working with other realtors that weren’t working out. Stephanie blew us away with her knowledge and attentiveness. She was always professional and always responded to us in a timely manner. What I loved best is that she was always honest with us and never just told us what we wanted to hear. She was polite, patient and respectful and made this nerve wracking experience an enjoyable one . She makes it fun it almost made us not want this journey to end once we found out home LOL. I definitely recommend her you won’t be dissapointed!!!
I knew of Stephanie through other people who used her expertise. I became friends with her on Facebook, and began to see how she operated. She was someone I wanted in my corner. When I decided to make the decision about selling my home, she was the one I reached out to. After our first conversation I knew I made the right choice, the best choice. Stephanie went above and beyond, and I am so glad she was there for me. She is someone who was an acquaintance who quickly became a lifelong friend. I would highly recommend her to everyone who is buying or selling. Simply the best!
Stephanie was our Agent when we sold our condo.We could not have made a better choice. Stephanie is extremely knowledgeable and hardworking and gets results. We can not say enough about how we enjoyed working with her. She was a great help during the whole process and we were fortunate to have her as our agent. We would highly recommended her to anyone.
Stephanie was amazing. She sold the house in one day at full ask. Guided us all the way with every challenge and was exceptionally helpful and honest. Her experience was amazing. She helped reduce our stress from beginning to end. I can’t imagine how it would have gone using someone else.
I would and do recommend Stephanie to anyone who is searching for their home! She made finding our first home fun, exciting, and as stress free as possible! She was on top of everything and kept everything we wanted in mind and the day she found our home she went above and beyond to make sure it became ours! I can’t express enough how amazing of a realtor she is and we gained such a great friend in the process. Thanks to her, we have the perfect home for our family!
Stephanie is absolutely the best!! She made the process of buying and selling as easy as possible. She sold my house in one open house and negotiated down my purchase price to where we were comfortable. She was available 24/7! Highly recommend!!!
Steph was instrumental in completing our recent home purchase in Setauket and her knowledge of the market helped with the negotiation process - and the litany of forms and functions to follow. Steph kept in touch via phone and text at any hour of the day with any questions we had, was available to meet and discuss in person, and advocated patience when necessary and action when warranted. We are very glad to have had her on our side and cannot recommend highly enough - plus we look forward to celebrating on the back porch soon! Thanks for all your assistance, Steph!
In a word... rockstar. Stephanie turned what is typically a stressful and emotional process into a fun enjoyable experience. Her wit and charm, paired with her extensive knowledge and experience in the business made me feel confident and comfortable with both selling my home and buying a new one with her. She always made herself available and offered advice I knew I could trust, while keeping my interest in mind. Stephanie Calinoff will remain the first and only real estate agent I would recommend and work with again.
Steph is AMAZING! She was so patient with us for every call, text, and question we had as first time home buyers. She listened to us and found us a house that had everything we wanted and more. She has the best energy and the biggest heart. I am lucky to now call Steph a friend.
Stephanie was always fair as my agent selling my house. She was a calming and rational voice during the whole process which as we all know can be a difficult process. I would recommend her to anyone who wants to buy or sell because her experience in and knowledge of the real estate field is invaluable.
Stephanie is amazing at getting back to you right away to answer any and all questions you may have every step of the process. It is very helpful during this stressful process! Definitely recommended!!
What can I say? Stephanie is the best. She found us a home that fit all my criteria. She was on our side during the negotiating process and got us the home right at our max budget but it was well worth it. She walked us through the entire home buying process and showed us homes that I didn't even know about on Zillow. She knows the area and the neighborhoods very well and was always available to show us properties even on weekends and evenings. Thanks Steph for working with us and we're looking forward to having you over once the renovations are done! Off to work I go to pay for those Long Island taxes! :(
Stephanie helped me purchase my new condo. She has been nothing but helpful and responsive. She took me out to look at condos and provided me with many options. Once we found the one I fell in love with, she did everything in her power to help me close the deal. I feel like I have known her forever. She is an awesome realtor and an even better person. Highly recommend her to anyone.
Stephanie sold us our first house 18yrs ago. So when we put our house on the market we immediately called her. She is very professional,thorough and as far as communication and response time she is incredible. I wouldn’t hesitate to refer her to anyone I know. We are extremely grateful and happy to have her in our life!
Stephanie represented the seller for a condo I just purchased and I thought so highly of her professonalism, responsiveness and personality as the buyer that I decided to write a review on her behalf. Should I ever need an agent in the future, I would undoubtedly reach out to Stephanie! She represented the seller well, but was fair and courteous to me in the process. Great person and agent.
Stephanie is a great person and agent to work with. She is knowledgeable about the area and the ins and outs of the business. We were so lucky to have her by our side answering our questions and keeping in touch with the buyers and lawyers. Stephanie Calinoff is the one to choose to sell or buy a home.
Working with Stephanie exceeded any of my expectations. As a first time homebuyer, I was not familiar with the terminology or the best process. But Stephanie never left any of my questions unanswered. She is not only knowledgeable, personable, endlessly patient, and incredibly generous with her time, but most of all, she is honest. If your are looking for a professional, approachable, and a straightforward agent, Stephanie is definitely a person you want to turn to. I work for an international corporation and I refer Stephanie to each coworker of mine with a confidence. Thank you for all your hard work and dedication Stephanie. You are the greatest!
If you are looking for a conscientious, competent and responsible real estate agent then Stephanie should definitely be your choice. Stephanie worked diligently with us to sell our home and also assisisted us in finding and purchasing a new home. We don't know much about buying and selling property but with Stephanie there looking out for our interests through sale and purchase all went very smoothly. Stephanie Calinoff is a real estate agent who will assist in all your needs in a caring and informative manner. We were lucky to have her on our side.
I have purchased and sold two homes with Stephanie Calinoff. I recommend her to anyone I meet who is looking to buy or sell a home. Stephanie keeps you informed and relaxed through the whole process. I am so happy to have met such a vibrant professional.
Stephanie did so much for my fiance and I in trying to find a house. We had tried shopping without an agent but once she came into the picture everything moved much more efficiently! She helped us find our home We are very grateful. I plan on reccomending her to our friends who will soon be going through the same process. Thank you Stephanie!
Stephanie was very flexible and understanding of our needs. Her years of experience led us to the perfect home for our family, my husband and I could not be happier. She has a great sense of humor and takes a lot of the anxiety out of the home shopping process. She was available and supportive every step of the way. We would definitely recommend her to friends and family.
My husband and I were looking to purchase our first home, and after searching tirelessly and unsuccessfully on our own, we were given Stephanie's information by a trusted family member. What a great decision it was to work with her...she did not disappoint!!! From the moment we met her, we instantly hit it off!! She is so down to earth, funny, friendly, and fun to be around. We quickly became friends, and she acted as such when finding us our perfect first home. She did not give us a sales pitch, and TRULY had our best interest in mind when helping us to find our home. Stephanie was not pushy at all, she was extremely honest and upfront, and even deterred us from certain homes that she knew we would not be happy in. She was very patient and understanding, too...she knows this is a big decision and certainly not something to rush into. Stephanie was always available and quick to get us into homes even before they were published on the market so we could have the first shot at them! We really had a wonderful and enjoyable experience working with Stephanie and we made great memories with her. She is the best and we would undoubtedly recommend her to our family and friends!!! Thank you for helping us to find the perfect home, Stephanie!!!
Stephanie went above and beyond to meet our needs when searching for our home. She worked with us as a friend and gave us her honest opinion of the houses she showed us. She was available by text day and night and arranged for showings around our schedule. I am thrilled she matched us to our perfect home.
SHE IS NOT THE ONE If what your looking for in an agent is someone to sell you a house directly under some power lines or maybe dead on the railroad tracks. Or maybe someone who will sell you something not in the school district of your choice, etc. all for the sake of a commission. Then I hate to disappoint you she is not the one. My wife and I met Stephanie back in 2000 when looking for our very first home. After dealing with some stiff and sometimes undesirable agents we contacted Steph by chance. Our first impression was this woman is crazy ( in a very very good way) her honesty and genuine sincerity was immediately plain to see. Also her sense of humor, which can throw some off a bit, was exactly what we needed at the time given the fact that it was our first home. Since that first purchase we have either bought or sold a total of 5 homes with Stephanie's help. Our most recent one was just this past October. She was even there to help us when we tried to make a go of living in PA. Even when there was no commission she helped us out and made sure we were in good hands through it all. Our trust in her judgement and skill set has gotten to the point over the years that I almost give her the keys and let her drive. I know she would never steer us wrong. At times she has protected me from myself. When I have become fixated on a home that was clearly wrong in every way she would help me see the light. Its kind of like having a real estate therapist. Stephanie has made home purchasing for me personally an almost worry free process ( there is always something to worry about ). She has always been available for our late night crazy question calls and her follow through is without comparison. She gets it done period. Her referrals are also spot on I really feel comfortable that who ever she recommends is also operating at the same level of excellence honesty and sincerity that Steph is. If this review seems a bit biased its probably because over all those years Stephanie has also become our friend but trust me anyone who knows us knows we tell it like it is. That's actually one of the primary reasons we like Stephanie. So in closing if you are looking for someone who is going to take a lot of the worry out of the home buying process. Someone who will sell you not just what you want but what you need. A person who will find what fits you not her. An individual who will look to establishing long lasting relationships not just commission. Then by all means SHE IS THE ONE Sometimes I joke that she will be helping us select our nursing home when the time comes.
Stephanie was a pleasure to work with. She was highly aware of all our needs and wants in finding a new home. She was knowledgable of local communities and neighborhoods that we were interested in. She has a great demeanor and sense of humor, which made the experience of finding a new home more fun than stressful! Thank you Stephanie!!
I chose Stephanie to be my realtor after reading her professional profile and reviews online. I also had a good feeling about her, considering the fact that she was a fellow redhead! Stephanie's work ethic and personality are what makes her one of the best agents around! The process of buying my co-op was a bit stressful, however Stephanie's humor kept me laughing throughout the process. I now consider Stephanie a friend and I'm so happy our paths have crossed. I would highly recommend Stephanie!
Stephanie is very helpful and responds very fast on any communication. She helped me show the house couple of time when ever I requested before I bought it. She always accompanied previous owner, so that I get answers to my question on the spot. She also helped Negotiating the price but to a certain extent. Over all I will definitely recommend her for your home selling/buying.
We bought and sold our first home with Stephanie and recently purchased our second and hopefully final home with her. From the day we met her, she has been nothing but the most patient, trustworthy, and respectful person as well as real estate agent we have ever met. We can honestly say she is more than our realtor but also our friend. She dealt with every obstacle that came our way in the most professional manner and truly helped us way beyond expectation. We love Stephanie and know that anyone who enlists her as their agent will be very happy.
Stephanie is the best! She is very knowledgeable, professional, and friendly. She is a pleasure to work with and is there for you whether you have a huge deal or a small one. We have had success with Stephanie over many years and property transactions. Every time we see the friends that referred Stephanie to us we thank them for the referral. There is no other realtor we will use!
Stephanie is the best agent you may find ever. She was so nice and helpful during all time we worked with her going looking for homes disregard of the weather or anything -- even with us being picky and not really knowing what do we need. She really helped us A LOT starting from searching and till the closing (and even after that), could recommend her to anyone without any doubts.
We were so blessed to have found Stephanie to be our agent. Not only was she knowledgable and on point with fulfilling all of our home finding needs but she is also a great person to be around!! Her humor and light heartedness made the whole home buying experience fun! She was with us every step of the way and after buying our home continues to be with us making sure we were doing fine. We found our forever home and a wonderful friend at the same time??
When we decided to look for a house we wanted someone who would be there for us and she was. She was professional, honest and made it an enjoyable experience for us . Stephanie was there for us every step of the way. She answered all of our questions and concerns right away anytime day or night. She helped us find not just a house but at home.
Stephanie is a beautiful, friendly, responsible and organized agent who has extensive real estate knowledge and strong negotiation skills. Impressive quick responses to all the questions. It is a great experience working with her!
Stephanie was absolutely AMAZING to work with when my girlfriend and I were purchasing our first home. Professional, hilarious, personable, responsive and diligent in every way you could possibly imagine. Our purchase was a bit high stress as it was our first purchase, we were pressed for time and the house we wanted had a number of issues that needed to be taken care of. But Stephanie was a complete pro and made sure the sale went through and we were happy with our buy. Can't recommend her enough!
The Calinoff winning tradition prove true with our encounter. Stephanie is not only an experienced professional, personable and has a uniquely witty charm that made this life event experience enjoyable. Our meeting was by chance, however once we met the pabdora box was opened; same birth month, same college, same dorm...now I can add the agent that help me achieve another milestone in my life-(A WIN-WIN) FINDING ME THE HOUSE THAT WAS IN MY HEART!!! Stephanie is just great; she took the time to learn my desires and wants, hear about my experiences & needs, and understood my limitations sincerely and incorporated all of that awareness into a seamless search for the home just for me. Meeting in July-closing in November. You do the math-the ending of this equation=FANTASTIC!!! Stephanie THANK YOU-
Stephanie helped me and my boyfriend buy our house. She was very easy to work with. Very helpful. She was always on our side when we needed her. I couldn't have picked a better agent. I can't thank her enough for helping us find our house!
We met Stephanie for the first time at an open house almost 2 years ago and fell in love with her. Her enduring personality just lures you in. About a year ago, my husband and I were ready to seriously start looking for houses. Unfortunately, we lost Stephanie's business card. We searched high and low, internet search after internet search and finally found her. She found us our dream home in our price range with in a few months. We enjoyed working with her so much that I decided to go for my real estate license and now I am working side by side with her.
Stephanie was instrumental in helping my fiance and I find a home to start our family. She truly cares for those she works with and makes your search a priority. I would gladly recommend Stephanie to anyone in search of a true professional.
We loved working with Stephanie. She helped us buy our new home, don't think we could've done it without her expertise! She is professional, knowledgable and fun to be around. She is highly recommended to anyone looking to buy a new home!
Although I did not have Stephanie as my agent, I would highly recommend her. I live in another state and when my sister contacted Stephanie after I interviewed a local agent to list my house and was very taken aback by his demeanor and comments and was frustrated about what to do next, Stephanie contacted me personally via phone and we spoke about my situation and frustration. She then took the time from her busy day to search for and contact a local agent for me that she felt I would be comfortable working with. I did list with that agent and recently just closed on my home. Stephanie went above and beyond for someone from another state she had never met, so I can trust that she would go above and beyond for her any and all of her clients.
Stephanie was great at attracting potential buyers to my home and as a result we went from posting the listing to being in contract in 3 months. She was also extremely helpful at answering any of our questions along the way.
We called Stephanie interested in renting a house because a previous mortgage company had turned us down and we figured we'd get the same response everywhere. Stephanie asked us the basic questions where are you looking to rent, how many bedrooms, bathrooms, but when it came to how much we could afford she asked why we weren't trying to buy something since we were willing to pay quite a bit per month for a rental. We explained our situation and she talked us Into meeting with her mortgage broker. He was amazing!! He had us pre-approved in a matter of days and looking at houses to buy within a week. Now less then 12 weeks later we're going to closing!! Stephanie was beyond amazing, patient, knowledgeable, and reassuring. I don't know if we would've ever gotten here without her help!! Any of you out there considering Stephanie as your agent, you're in great hands!! And her mortgage company CHL is just as wonderful!!
There is no way to express how amazing Stephanie has been during our home buying process. She was honest with us from the beginning about the process of purchasing a short sale and the difficulties we might face. However, she made the entire process as pain and stress free as possible. She was always available to answer any questions we had along the way and kept us informed of everything that was happening. We felt like her top priority and without her attentiveness and knowledge I do not think we would be in this home today. Stephanie is an excelent person to have on your side while trying to purchase a home and I cannot recomend her enough. I know from experience she will work tirelessly to ensure you are comfortable, informed, and in control of the entire home buying experience. I would and will recomend Stephanie to all of my friends and family when buying a home. We were constantly in touch through the entire process and never felt that she was too busy to answer even the smallest questions. We cannot recommend Stephanie enough and can confidently say she is the best realtor to have on your team.
First thing I have to say is. I am sorry to Stephanie for taking so long to write.. what a phonomenl job Stephanie did for us. I don't have to say to the most of us moving and buying a home is a stressful nerve-wracking and emotional up and down experience. Stephanie did a great job leading us thru the up and down Rollercoaster ride. And she did in a very professional and relaxed manner. I would highly recommend her to any one going through with buying a home.
I know that any people who write reviews are either extremely disappointment or extremely happy with how they have been taken care of. I am happy to say that I am writing this review based on the latter and that I am more than satisfied with the work that Stephanie has done in selling my home. From day one she has treated my wife and I like family and she has shown genuine concern and understanding every step of the way through the process. Stephanie is very responsive day or night and she had a great strategy in selling our home. Even though the weather did not cooperate on many weekends, Stephanie was vigilant in scheduling open houses and doing everything she could to get people in our home. If you are looking for an agent that is responsive, caring and professional I would suggest that you look no further and contact Stephanie Calinoff!
Stephanie is a wonderful agent. She's professional, attentive and very funny. She made the process of buying a house enjoyable. She has a great team of real estate professionals working with her, and they can handle every real estate situation. Stephanie will work tirelessly to help you sell, or buy a home.
After I decided to sell my house I was nervous about going through the process. Stephanie made the whole experience not only tolerable but stress free. Her knowledge and friendly character made me feel comfortable leaving the whole process in her hands. She gave me invaluable advice that made all the difference when I had to make difficult decisions. As a result I sold my house for the amount I expected and it was all done within a couple of months.<br/><br/>I would and have recommend her to my friends and family.....
Stephanie was professional, friendly and has full knowledge of Long Island. She made me feel like I was her only client by making herself available and responding quickly. I would highly recommend her to anyone in need of an agent.
Stephanie Calinoff was an absolute pleasure to work with from the moment we made contact. Always eagerly available through the process of buying our first home, acknowledged our concerns and requests and anticipated our needs with careful guidance. We were in the best of hands in finding and negotiating our home where we will build dreams with our children for many years to come. She made certain we entertained options to meet our needs and I would most definitely recommend Stephanie Calinoff to any of my friends and family. In fact, I consider her family now!!!! Thank you Stephanie for all you have done for the Jensen Family in making our dreams a reality!!!!!!!<br/><br/> Mr. & Mrs. George Jensen & kiddos!!!!!!
Stephanie is the best agent and we knew we loved her from the first minute meeting her. After meeting several duds and out for themselves agents, we were so thrilled to find someone as honest as Stephanie. She made us feel comfortable from day one and never made us feel like we were being forced to just buy anything. After a year of searching we finally found our home and a lifetime friend. We love you Stephanie ?
We had the pleasure of working with Stephanie when buying our first home, and she was absolutely wonderful throughout the entire process, making it as painless as possible. I would highly recommend Stephanie to anyone looking for an experienced professional with a great personality and sense of humor. We couldn't have asked for a better real estate agent!
I was so happy to give my cousin the referral of Stephanie Calinoff, when she asked me for help in looking for a condo. I gave her Stephanie's contact information along with my own little message, stating "you will love her". Well, my cousin absolutely did love her, as a matter of fact, she loved her so much, that Stephanie and my cousin became inseparable during the entire process. Fortunately, closing was last week and I have my cousin back.... My cousin was so impressed with Stephanie and so grateful to have her become a part of her life. Stephanie not only takes you on as a client, she takes you on as family, and you will be treated that way, from beginning to end!!! Thank you Stephanie Calinoff!!!! Xoxo
Never had I trusted any real estate professional as much as I have trusted Stephanie Calinoff. Stephanie was not just a professional but she was a friend. I have bought a house and sold a house with Stephanie and each time, she made me feel like her most important client. She was my advocate in every way.
Steph is one of the most down to earth people out there. She is reliable and honest. She will do everything in her power to make your experience a pleasant one. I should know, I have had 3 transactions with Steph. The best part is you will have a ton of fun and she will make you laugh until your sides hurt. That was the best part for us... she's personable and fun. I would recommend her to anyone and certainly look forward to using her again.
Stephanie worked with my family during the very quick sale of our home and the long process of finding the "right" new home. Her patience, understanding of the market and personal touch made a difficult time a little easier. She is professional and direct and knows the market, She took the time to understand our needs and held our hand up to closing and beyond. We even shared a few laughs along the way. We highly recommend Stephanie whether you are looking to list your home or looking to purchase. You will be in good hands.
Stephanie is one of the most professional real estate agents I could have ever met. She does everything with a smile on her face and a laugh to brighten your day. She is a wonderful agent who cares so much about her "sellers" and "buyer" All her listings are taken care of directly by her. She is on top of each move that goes on from the time she takes the listing until it closes (in a short amount of time). I HIGHLY recommend Stephanie Calinoff because she cares about all her clients, buyers and sellers alike. This woman is a Class Act!!
It seems corny to five star someone across the board unless it might be Stephanie. Stephanie is certainly a unique person in many ways. Her expertise in her business gives her the right to be cocky if she want to but she just goes with the fun flow. I had several business dealings with Stephanie and she always comes out on top. Its basic etiquette. She does what she is supposed to do. She sold my Hauppauge house a few years ago without a hitch. As I say, she is a pro. She gets the job done, and without breaking a sweat. Its' really quite simple. Be the best at what you do and it comes a bit easier after a while. Stephanie is one who is admired by many. People that know her, trust her and its that simple. I would use her again in the future without hesitation.
My husband and I have worked very closely with Stephanie on selling our home. We have also used Stephanie to buy a house. We were extremely happy with the results of both transactions. She is a very dedicated, informative and a helpful real estate agent. I have recommended Stephanie to many friends and family. She knows her stuff!
Purchased a co-op in Selden. Overall Stephanie Calinoff was helpful and pleasant. She did a good job in showing the apartment. I was very pleased. SHe did a good job in showing the property, helping me getting the unit inspected by a housing inspector and the co-op and in the walkthrough.
Reviews from Google and Zillow, shown as written. Read every review on Google or Zillow.
Her sales, in numbers
Sales figures: OneKey MLS, 2012 to November 2026, from Stephanie Calinoff's own closed transactions.
Recent sales
View all
Sold November 3, 2026
344 Ontario Avenue
5 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,796 Sq.Ft.
$760,000
Listed by Stephanie Calinoff, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker, Signature Premier Properties
Sold October 22, 2026
9 Dillmont Drive
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 1,870 Sq.Ft.
$750,000
Listed by Stephanie Calinoff, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker, Signature Premier Properties
Sold October 20, 2026
51 Hastings Drive
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,798 Sq.Ft.
$732,500
Listed by Stephanie Calinoff, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker, Signature Premier Properties
Sold October 19, 2026
115 Cedar Avenue
3 Beds | 1.5 Baths | 1,136 Sq.Ft.
$615,000
Listed by Stephanie Calinoff, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker, Signature Premier Properties
Sold October 1, 2026
29 Maplewood Avenue
2 Beds | 1 Baths | 960 Sq.Ft.
$360,000
Listed by Stephanie Calinoff, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker, Signature Premier Properties
Sold September 24, 2026
19 Paine Commons
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,778 Sq.Ft.
$510,000
Listed by Stephanie Calinoff, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker, Signature Premier Properties
Neighborhood guides
Follow along
@stephaniecalinoffHow much is your home worth?
- A number from her sales, not a formula
- Straight advice
- Priced to sell, not to sit
Receive exclusive listings in your inbox
Interested in buying a home? Hear about new listings from Stephanie before they hit the portals.
By submitting you agree to be contacted by Stephanie Calinoff about real estate services. You can opt out at any time.
Work with Stephanie
Ready to make your next move? Talk to Stephanie and get a straight answer on price, timing and what to fix first.
Stephanie Calinoff
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
- Phone number
- Mobile: (516) 729-3717
- Address
- 7 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787
Signature Premier Properties, Licensed Real Estate Broker