Equal Housing Opportunity NYS Housing and Anti-Discrimination Notice

Signature Premier Properties, 7 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787 Office: (631) 360-2800

Signature Premier Properties
Stephanie Calinoff at Signature Premier Properties

Licensed at eighteen. Taught by her mother. Selling Long Island homes since 1985.

Stephanie Calinoff, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker, Signature Premier Properties, Smithtown

Stephanie Calinoff, Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
  • 41years licensed in New York
  • 407closed transactions since 2012 alone
  • 54towns with a closed sale

Smithtown, from the start

Stephanie grew up here. Her father, Lenny Calinoff, ran an automotive store in Smithtown; her mother, Elaine, sold Long Island real estate for more than thirty years. Stephanie was licensed at eighteen and learned the work the way you learn a family business: next to someone who was very good at it.

The marketing is not an afterthought

Before real estate took over, she earned a Bachelor of Fine Arts in graphic design at C.W. Post and worked in creative marketing. It still shows. A Calinoff listing is designed: photography, print, social media and digital advertising, carried by a network of personal and professional contacts built over four decades.

“Your home does not just go on the market. It stays in the market until it sells.”

Stephanie Calinoff

Clients who come back

One client has worked with Stephanie on nineteen sales and purchases across eight years, including homes for her children. Others met her at an open house they walked into without an agent, and called afterward to say they wanted her on their side of the table. Most of her business runs on relationships like these: repeat clients, their families, and the people they send her.

The work today

She works from the Signature Premier Properties office on West Main Street in Smithtown and sells across Suffolk County: Smithtown, Saint James, Hauppauge and the towns around them, for sellers and buyers in about equal measure, from single family homes to 55 and over communities. For clients leaving Long Island, or arriving, there is Calinoff Connection.

How Stephanie works a listing

  1. Meet before the number

    The first question most sellers ask is the commission. Stephanie would rather meet first and walk through how she will market the house, represent you and negotiate for you, so you know what the number pays for before you hear it.

  2. Keep the house in the market

    A listing is not only put on the market. Stephanie keeps it visible with social media, digital advertising, print and a network of personal and professional contacts built over four decades.

  3. One person, beginning to closing

    Stephanie guides every step herself, from the first meeting to the closing table. When you call about your sale, you reach the person who has handled it from the start.

  4. Sellers who are also buying

    Many of her clients are selling and buying at once, moving into a 55 and over community, or leaving Long Island. Stephanie plans both sides of the move together so one does not wait on the other.

Stephanie Calinoff works at Signature Premier Properties, Licensed Real Estate Broker, at 7 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787. The brokerage handles the compliance, escrow and legal side, which is the part that should be boring and usually is.

What clients say about Stephanie

5.0 from 48 reviews on Google and 5.0 from 69 reviews on Zillow

Stephanie’s experience in the business was very impressive and really shone through during the home buying Process. Plus, she is hilarious and fun to work with!!

Kaitlyn Wahl Google, November 2026

Stephanie was just great. Her patience in helping us find "just the rigjt home" was fantastic, and we were very very picky to say the least. Stephanie really made sure we seen different places to ensure we would find the place we really wanted. Her friendly sense of humor always kept our house hunting light and lively. Stephanie simply is someone youbwould want to be alongside of you during your house hunting experience.

Frank Korzeniewski Google, July 2026

The worst part about Steph and Joe… is that they’ll find you your dream home way too quickly and you won’t get to spend more of your time with them. We thought finding our first home would be incredibly difficult and frustrating, but Steph and Joe made the entire process so easy and fun. They were there day and night to answer our questions and hold our hands through the process. Their experience and knowledge is invaluable, but they also genuinely care about getting you into the right home. They’re great realtors, but even better people. I can not recommend them enough! 10/10, no notes.

Michael Lombardo Google, June 2026

We were struggling a bit with this review because we didn't want to come off as if we were getting paid to write it. Ultimately we decided to let the facts speak for themselves. My wife and I met Stephanie during the search for our first house over 27 years ago. In all that time Stephanie has helped us buy and sell a total of 7 homes for a total of 11 transactions to date. At one point she even helped us with an out of state relocation. After the first transaction we immediately realized that she did things differently from other agents. Since then our transactions have became a thing of real TRUST. Stephanie genuinely listens to us and never tries to steer or influence. At times even protecting us from ourselves when we have wanted to look at houses that we later came to realize would have been bad for us. Any attorney or finance agent she has recommended has always turned out to be top notch and it is an added bonus that she has access to these individuals during off hours. You know those moments when you want an answer to something but don't want to call your attorney at 10 P.M. Well she can and will on your behalf if the situation calls for it. She herself is always easy to reach and she will get that answer that you need. On this last transaction we joked that she is our artist and that we would just let her paint. Let me tell you she did not disappoint we bought / sold in one swoop and nothing is ever perfect but this transaction was close enough. I will wrap it up by stating that over these years she has become more than our agent. She is also a great friend. It doesn't matter that we don't connect, sometimes for months at a time, but when we do we pick up right where we left off. My wife and I will often joke that Stephanie will be representing us when it comes time for our nursing home accommodations. There are many good agents out there but you would be hard pressed to find someone as good and as real as Stephanie.

Jose Villanueva Google, March 2026

Stephanie is great. She will make you laugh and stick by your side throughout the whole process and after. She’s an amazing person and really passionate about her occupation.

Dario Regiani Google, March 2026

Great experience, would absolutely recommend Stephanie to anyone looking to buy a home. She is very friendly, but definitely not afraid to stand up for her client. You could tell that she really cares about helping you find the best place to fit your needs.

Jeff Stone Google, March 2026

It was such a pleasure to work with Stephanie. Stephanie and her team were all amazing throughout the entire home buying process. In this competitive housing market, the home buying process could have been such a challenge. Thanks to the expertise, reliability and guidance from Stephanie! We were able to navigate our way to finding a great forever home. From the very beginning, Stephanie made it a priority that our house search is targeted to the criteria we are looking for. Because we feel confident that we are constantly guided by a knowledgeable realtor like Stephanie, the home search experience becomes more and more enjoyable! The love and care Stephanie puts in to making her clients happy and satisfied is extra incredible. You are the best, Stephanie Calinoff!! Thank you!

IQ Barcelon Google, March 2026

Stephanie Calinoff has been amazing! She found our dream home and we couldn’t have done it without her and her team. Highly recommend!

anthony critelli Google, February 2026

Stephanie is fantastic!! She made the whole process very easy for us in our difficult time. I would recommend her to anyone who is looking to buy or sell. Even if you just have a few questions , she has so much knowledge to offer. Thank you Stephanie!!

Ginny Poole Google, February 2026

Reviews from Google and Zillow, shown as written. Read every review on Google or Zillow.

Start with a conversation

Selling, buying, or just trying to figure out what a house is worth before you decide anything.

Get in touch Mobile: (516) 729-3717

Stephanie Calinoff Talk to Stephanie