Long Island
Who is the best real estate agent on Long Island?
There is no single best agent on Long Island, and any page telling you otherwise is selling something. What there is, is a sales history you can check. Stephanie Calinoff is a Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker with Signature Premier Properties, working mainly in Coram, Smithtown, Selden and Medford. Below is what her sales history actually shows, with the basis for each figure beside it.
What the sales history shows
- 198 listings sold Homes listed and sold, 2012 to 2026. Each has a page on this site.
- 209 buyers represented Purchases closed for buyers. These listings belonged to other brokerages, so they are counted here and are not shown as listings anywhere on this site.
- $178,693,744 in closed volume Sum of the closing prices across all 407 closings, both sides.
- 24 days on market, median Median across sales with a known days-on-market value. Half sold faster.
- 101% of asking price, average Closing price against list price, averaged over 198 sales where both are known.
Sales figures: OneKey MLS, 2012 to November 2026, from Stephanie Calinoff's own closed transactions. Every sale behind these figures is published on this site with its address, price and closing date.
“Best” means different things
It is worth being specific about this, because the answer changes depending on what you are trying to do. Someone selling a house that has already sat on the market wants something different from someone buying their first.
- Volume
- How much an agent actually closes. It is the easiest thing to verify and the easiest to misread: a high number across a whole county says less about your street than a smaller number concentrated in it. 198 listings sold, 209 buyers represented, $178,693,744 in total.
- Local depth
- Repeat sales in the same few towns. This is the one that tends to matter most and gets advertised least, because it is a smaller number than a county-wide total. 25 towns with three or more closed sales.
- Pricing accuracy
- Whether houses sell near what they were listed at. Consistently far above asking can mean strong demand, and it can also mean the list price was low. 101% of asking on average, across 198 sales.
- Current activity
- Whether the agent is working now, not five years ago. Closings in every year from 2012 to 2026.
Two things this page deliberately does not claim: a ranking against other agents, and a percentile. This site carries Stephanie’s own transactions and not the full market compilation, so a percentile calculated here would be a guess. If a ranking matters to you, the third-party sites that publish them are the place to check, and you should check more than one.
Towns with a closed sale behind them
Ordered by how many. A town page on this site is built from these sales, which is why there is not one for every place on Long Island.
- Coram 18
- Smithtown 16
- Selden 12
- Medford 11
- Centereach 11
- Ronkonkoma 11
- Holbrook 8
- Nesconset 6
- Farmingville 6
- Saint James 6
- Hauppauge 6
- Stony Brook 5
- Port Jefferson Station 5
- Middle Island 5
- Mount Sinai 5
- Patchogue 4
- Lake Grove 4
- Ridge 4
- Port Jefferson 3
- Sound Beach 3
- Miller Place 3
- Islandia 3
- Huntington Station 3
- Holtsville 3
- Lake Ronkonkoma 3
Questions people actually ask
- How many homes has Stephanie Calinoff sold on Long Island?
- 198 homes listed and sold between 2012 and 2026, each with a page on this site showing its address, price and closing date, plus 209 purchases closed for buyers, where the listing belonged to another brokerage. $178,693,744 in closing prices across both.
- Which towns does Stephanie Calinoff actually work in?
- Most often Coram, Smithtown, Selden, Medford and Centereach. The full list of towns with a closed sale behind it is on this site, and each town page is built from those sales rather than from a general description of the area.
- What brokerage does Stephanie Calinoff work with?
- Signature Premier Properties, a licensed real estate broker at 7 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787.
- How long do her listings take to sell?
- The median is 24 days on market across her closed sales, which means half sold faster than that. Speed depends on the house and the price it is listed at, and a median is the ordinary case rather than a promise about any particular listing.
Ask Stephanie directly
The most useful thing is usually a conversation about the specific house and the specific street, which is where an average stops being much help.
